Does being better than your competition actually matter? Or is it enough to be m

By Marktaw · November 19, 2026 · Curated by George's Blog

Does being better than your competition actually matter? Or is it enough to be memorable?

Clayton Christensen's seminal book The Innovator's Dilemma argues that yes - being superior along some dimension actually matters.

Small steel mills were willing to take on the small complex projects. The stuff big steel wouldn't bother with - too much effort for too little money. Eventually the small steel mills toppled the big ones.

Case closed, differentiation matters. Build a better mousetrap and you'll gain market share. But (my god is it) 30 years later and this is still the hottest debate in marketing.

I tend to think of any buying decision as being scored out of 100 points. Highest score wins.

There are some things people care about, but not that much. Table stakes. "Car is reliable." Then there are the things few people care about, but care about so passionately that they study every nuance of - traction control, cornering, decibels at highway speed, etc.

Each of those can be worth 20 points - but how hard it is to earn those 20 points matters a lot. "Car is reliable" is a checkbox - everyone they don't have active disdain for gets 20 points. But if the car can get you safely through the snow, so much so that they make videos of you towing other cars out of the snow? Yeah this brand gets 7 points, that brand gets 9 points, and some other brand gets 17 points. Nobody gets all 20 points - these people really *care* about this shit. Or they could write a book about the brand that gets all 20 points.

This is what Jiri Boudal argues in his brilliant article & study. Differentiation - actually being better than the competition along some dimension - actually does matter *for challenger brands*.

Wiemer Snijders had commented the other day on some study about how small brands tend to have more positive Google reviews than larger brands. Could this be evidence for differentiation? Successful smaller brands are often better at something, and therefore more beloved.

Talk to someone who's passionate about coffee and they'll mention a place you've never heard of in a neighborhood you've never been to, but sails their beans in on a sailboat, and the beans dry in the sun on the boat, absorbing the salt air and pelican poop - an important component of the flavor, like civet coffee but pelicans!

When a brand gets big enough, that small cohort of people doesn't make much impact on brand size.

So there we have it. How do brands grow™? Be better at something people actually care about AND be funny looking.* Which is more important depends on how big your brand is.

* or at least distinctive

PS - speaking of 30 year old business case studies, remember when reliability wasn't a thing cars were known for? Then suddenly Toyota comes along and literally every other car maker tried to figure out how to make their cars as reliable? Distinctive or differentiation?

View the original post on LinkedIn