With its buttery aroma, crisp golden pastry, and aromatic mincemeat, these Which
By Oliver Bradley · November 17, 2026 · Curated by George's Blog
With its buttery aroma, crisp golden pastry, and aromatic mincemeat, these Which? Best Buy pies were a triumph, scoring 73% and beating all other UK mince pie contenders.
The Which? tasters loved the simple, rustic appearance that "could almost pass as homemade."
The mincemeat filling was well-balanced and not too sweet, allowing the fruit flavours to shine. One judge raved: "I could snuffle at least two before slowing down."
Read the full WHICH? review here: https://lnkd.in/dD25vfik?
Sadly for Waitrose, anyone shopping on a mobile will never know.
Their hero image scored an outright FAIL on RHINO. Aside from "Nº1", nearly every critical text element on the pack sits between 0% and 7% Glance-Readability.
That is serious visual friction.
Showing up with the best-tasting product and then making your pack unreadable on a phone means you get missed in the scroll this Christmas.
Online shoppers don't read. They glance.
If they can't work out what it is within milliseconds, they swipe straight to a competitor.
Settling for physical packaging compliance on digital shelves leaves revenue on the table. Test your hero images for mobile screens before you push them live.
All shoppers know is that these are mince pies.
Knowing they are the Waitrose brand ones - well, that's like watching "Mission Impossible" at Christmas.