Clients want transformation. Then, they write a brief that prevents it... There'
By Ivanfernandes1 · November 16, 2026 · Curated by George's Blog
Clients want transformation. Then, they write a brief that prevents it...
There's something rather ironic about the agency pitch process.
- Clients want innovation.
- Marketing transformation.
- AI-enabled capabilities.
- New operating models.
They want agencies to challenge conventional thinking, rethink how marketing works and deliver something fundamentally different.
Then, they issue a brief that tells agencies...
1) What services to provide.
2) How to organise themselves.
3) How many people should deliver the work.
We wonder why so many pitches end up looking remarkably similar.
Perhaps the biggest mistake in an agency pitch happens before the agencies are even invited. I've experienced agency pitches from almost every side of the table.
- As an agency executive competing for business.
- At Oystercatchers, helping clients conduct agency reviews.
- Alongside global CMOs, procurement and technology teams evaluating agencies and technology partners.
Those experiences have taught me something.
We spend considerably more time questioning agencies than questioning the assumptions behind the brief. We scrutinise capabilities, credentials, staffing, technology and pricing. However, how often do we ask whether the client actually needs the operating model it is buying?
- What if the best solution requires fewer agencies?
- Less outsourced work?
- More automation?
- Or a completely different combination of capabilities?
👉 Would we reward the agency brave enough to challenge the brief? Or eliminate it for not answering the question?
This isn't about blaming procurement.
Nor is it about giving agencies a free pass.
It's about recognising that how clients buy marketing services shapes the kind of agencies the industry produces.
In my latest article, drawing on our What Comes Next initiative, I explore why the agency review itself may need reinventing.
We've spent years asking agencies to change.
Perhaps it's time clients questioned whether they're prepared to buy something different. Because you can't keep buying yesterday's marketing operating model and expect tomorrow's results.
ivanfernandes.me